I began my first layout based on the Piedmont Subdivision back in the fall of 2000. When I finalized my original track plan, I was pretty happy with it. The only major change that I made (and one that I had contemplated even as I started construction) was to pierce the backdrop in Gordonsville and add staging tracks. For the most part, things worked out the way that I planned and I started adding scenery (you can take a tour of that layout as of the summer of 2010 here). As I was working on the scenery, I started trying to operate the layout. That’s when I ran into issues that I just wasn’t able to resolve. Here’s a list of the major ones:
In 2011 I became the sole owner of my home. The whole basement was now mine to do with as I pleased. I almost immmediately began drawing track plans that took most (or all) of the space. Those plans usually involved moving Louisa and Gordonsville farther apart, adding staging in a way that trains entered the layout at the appropriate points, and often involved the addition of a siding between Louisa and Melton so that I could model the lumberyard in Trevilian. None of them really caught my fancy, however, so my model railroad languished for about 5 years; I was loathe to put effort into something that I planned to tear down. The only real change made was that I removed the staging tracks in order to replace my water heater. I took the opportunity to have the heater moved to a place where it would be out of the way of a redesign.
In early 2016, though, I had a number of important insights about why I wasn’t able to make any progress on a new track plan. The first concerned my home office, which is also in the basement. Most of my plans devoted my office space to the new layout. My first important insight was that I really didn’t want to do that. My office is a nice space where I spend a lot of time. Further, a big feature of the room is a set of floor-to-ceiling bookcases (which are stuffed) that were gifts from my Dad and sized to fit where they are. There’s nowhere else in the house that they would fit.
The second insight was that most of my plans also involved a duckunder to reach my laundry facilities or they potentially blocked access to the circuit breakers for the house. I’m nearing 60 years of age and I don’t want to have to duck under the layout carrying a basket full of laundry. The final insight came after reading the 2016 issue of Model Railroad Planning. I had been trying to include enough staging for all of the trains that I wanted to run in an operating session: locals each way between Richmond and Charlottesville, locals each way between Potomac Yard and Charlottesville, a manifest freight each way, and sections of the George Washington each way between Richmond and Charlottesville and between Washington and Charlottesville. To do that, I had to give up the possibility of continuous running (which I will admit that I enjoy - sometimes it’s fun to just sit back and just watch the trains go by) and staging was taking up a huge amount of the space that I had available. The insight from MRP was that maybe I didn’t need to provide all that staging. Maybe what would work would be a fiddle yard. And, with that, I was on my way.
As with my earlier layout, there were certain things that I wanted in my new layout — my givens and druthers in John Armstrong’s terms. Those included:
The plan above represents what I’ve come up with so far (click the image to see a higher res version). This plan allows me to keep my office and access to the laundry facilities and electrical stuff on the left-hand wall of the basement. The fiddle yard beside the stairs allows me to stage two trains in each direction at the same time and trains enter the modeled section of the layout in the correct places. I had to give up the possibility of modeling the Pot Yard locals and the Washington sections of the George, but I think I can live with that (and I might eventually find a way to add removable staging that would allow running those trains during an operating session).
In addition, I had resources available this time that I didn’t back in 2000. One of the most important was an aerial photo of the wye in Gordonsville. It was detailed enough that I could work out the scale and the radius of the curves through the wye. In 2000 I guessed 53". Using the photo I found that I was close, but off by a bit. What I came out with this time was 56.25". I was also able to space some of the turnouts a little closer to the prototype and include both of the sidings across the mainline from the freight house, so my when I begin to add scenery everything should look right. The plan also included a short siding near Louisa to represent the Purcell lumberyard in Bibb. The idea was that including the lumberyard would go a little way toward making up for losing the vermiculite loader. I did, however, also include the siding that eventually served the vermiculite loader. It was there in 1970 (it served an auto loading ramp in the 1930’s). After beginning construction of the layout I found an aerial photo of the area from 1969. There was some sort of building along the siding that was there as early as the 1950’s. According to Gary Smith, it belonged to a feed company. Other than the fact that it was rectangular in shape, was described in one document as metal, and had a ramp, I have no real idea what it looked like, but I’ll probably try to represent it on the layout.
I did receive some very thoughtful suggestions from Jerry Simonoff. One was to reorient Louisa so that it was consistent with Gordonsville and Melton. I think I’ve addressed my reasons for not doing so above. He also suggested double ending the fiddleyard tracks and using some of them to represent some of the trackage in Lindsay. I’m giving both of those serious consideration and trying to figure out how I could do that without making the benchwork at the apex of the turnback between Gordonsville and the fiddle yard too deep. There is obviously going to have to be a duckunder somewhere and that seems to be the best location. I also have to be careful of the space between the fiddle yards and the heat pump. I need access there to change the filters.
I’m still in the planning stages, a great idea could still be incorporated. I’d like to hear your thoughts. Feel free to email me at the address below.
|The first thing I did was to mount a backrop made of 1/8" hardboard. I just continued the backdrop straight into the corners on my old railroad and forever had to avoid taking photos from angles that would show the corners in the “sky.” This time I curved the backdrop through the corners. It wasn’t as hard as I thought it was going to be and it avoids the “corners in the sky” problem.|
|Most of the layout is going to be anchored to the wall. This bracket — which follows a design from Jeff Wilson’s benchwork book — was fairly simple to build, does a great job of supporting the layout, and leaves more space under the layout. That makes it easier to work under the layout (say, when I need to do wiring) and gives me more room to store back issues of magazines.|
|In this shot, I’ve mounted the first of the L-girders. I needed to get this one up so that I could construct the first free-standing section of benchwork, which will be anchored to this L-girder.|
|Before I started building the layout, I had my 22-year-old heat pump replaced. After the installation, I checked the trackplan against the footprint of the new unit. Everything looked fine, so I started construction. Too bad that I wasn’t thinking in three dimensions, though. When I reached this point it was clear that the ductwork was going to interfere with the backdrop. After studying the problem for a few days, I decided to shift the backdrop and the track toward the front edge of the bechwork. Around the same time, my water heater (which is right next to the inside unit of the heat pump) started leaking and I had to have it replaced. It was only 6 years old. The idea that I might have to replace the new one in another 6 years forced me to decide that the track looping around the water heater should be removable to facilitate access to the heater. That plus the backdrop move cost me the ability to include the Purcell lumberyard as I had originally planned.|
|In this shot, the backdrop has been painted. I don’t plan to add clouds. I try to avoid adding things to the layout that undermine believability. That includes things that should move, but don’t, such as a figure of a man jogging. He might look good in a still photo, but watching him frozen in midstride undermines the illusion when visiting the layout in person. Clouds move and the same ones would not be hanging overhead day after day after day. So, I left them off.|
|This photo (and the next one, as well) show the layout after all of the L-girders and joists have been assembled.|
|The risers and plywood subroadbed have been installed and the first of the precut cork switch pads have been glued down.|
|The cork roadbed went in quickly.|
|Several tracklaying guides suggested starting with the most complicated track first. For me, that was the west (on the layout) end of Louisa. In this shot, the first couple of switches have been installed. Underneath the layout are the Blue Point switch controllers.|
|In this shot, the curve leading into Melton can be seen. On my previous layout I had problems maintaining my 30" minimum radius as I laid the track through curves. Fast Tracks SweepSticks (the wooden template between the rails) helped solve that problem.|
|The wiring for the track is in. I used 14-guage wire for the bus lines and 22-guage wire for the feeders. I used suitcase connectors for most of the connections, so the wiring went pretty quickly.|
|Finding a place to put my DCC system was a bit of an afterthought on the old layout. This time, I put some thought into the location. It had to be fairly close to an outlet and easily accessible. What I came up with was a shelf below the narrow benchwork near the heatpump. As you can see, I use a Lenz DCC system with LH90 hand controllers. Next up is to install the layout fascia so that I can wire up the ExpressNet plugs.|
|Rather than proceeding with the fascia, I decided to finish the rest of the benchwork. Here’s the first section of benchwork that is situated in new layout space. Gordonsville will be located in the corner by the door.|
|The open grid benchwork in the near foreground will support the turnback curve between Gordonsville and the staging tracks. This is the location of the duckunder to enter the layout area and using open grid benchwork bought me a few extra inches of clearance above the ground. That’s a few extra inches that I don’t have to bend down.|
|I’ve got a coat of primer on the new section of backdrop.|
|Once the primer dried and I fixed a couple of rough spots, I put on a coat of sky blue. I still have a couple of spots begging for some light sanding and touch up paint.|
|Laying out the track plan on the plywood subroadbed for the first part of the layout was fairly easy; there were lots of straight lines and curves with radii that could be drawn by drilling holes in a yardstick. The trackwork in Gordonsville, though, was much more complicated and involved 56.25" radius curves. I first thought of drilling holes in a spare tape measure I have, but discovered that even if that would work, I don’t have space to do it. I finally resorted to printing out my trackplan full size using xTrkCad (which involved 22 pieces of paper that I then had to tape together). I taped the trackplan down to the plywood and used pushpins to mark the track center lines. Then I pulled up the paper and joined up the pin marks with pencil.|
|The subroadbed in Gordonsville is up on risers. Right below the camera’s position is the location of the bridge over Route 15/33. I salvaged the scratchbuilt model of that bridge that I built for my old layout. The trick now is to work out how to fit it in here.|
|I put my cardboard mockup of the Gordonsville freight station in place to make sure that everything fits as planned. The sharp-eyed will note that the track centerlines here don’t quite match the trackplan shown above. As I laid things out full-sized I realized that I needed to change some things. First, I placed the turnout leading into the siding that served the freighthouse in the wrong place. If I had placed it according to the plan, it would have been right in front of the freighthouse. That was an easy fix; I just moved it a few feet to the “east.” I also eliminated one of the sidings across the main from the freighthouse. I had done that on the old layout, too, and it bugged me. So, I added it into the new plan. However, seeing the everything full-sized reminded me of why I’d left it out back in 2000: adding it crowded the scene to the point that it looked cartoonish because that second siding couldn’t be long enough to be reasonable. So, I eliminated it. I now have an extra Atlas Code 83 left-hand turnout on hand.|
|The cork roadbed is now down in Gordonsville. I used HO scale roadbed for the mainline and N scale roadbed for sidings. One issue on the old layout was the depth of the benchwork through Gordonsville. To work the siding for the freighthouse required standing on a step ladder and reaching over an area that was going to have to be populated with models of the Main Street stores. I cut the depth back significantly in the new plan.|
|It took days of fiddling with the risers and stacking bits of plywood to get bridge 1605 into place and level from end to end and front to back.|
|Right after I started connecting feeders in Gordonsville, I remembered that I needed to cut gaps in some of the rails so that I could wire in block occupancy detectors to trigger grade crossing flashers. The first step was to mark where the roads will be.|
|I was looking for something else when I found my cardboard mockup of G cabin. Having found it, though, it had to end up on the layout.|
|Fitting a Blue Point switch controller in place to operate the turnout just off the east end of the bridge was a bit of an adventure.|
|To the left in this photo is the Westvaco pulpwood siding and to the right is the track that forms the Washington Subdivision side of the Gordonsville wye.|
|This is an overall view of the fiddle yard. Richmond staging is to the left, Charlottesville to the right. In the left foreground, the mainline crosses over the water heater.|
|This section of the mainline is designed to be removable to allow easier access should the water heater need to be replaced. I plan to put some kind of sides on it, both the protect against drops to the floor in the case of a derailment and to add some additional rigidity.|
|In this shot, I’ve begun installing the fascia. It’s made of ⅛ hardboard.|
|I painted the fascia a nice dark green colr (Behr’s Eastern Bamboo, to be exact). Now that the worst of the mess construction is done, I’ve set up a computer to run Decoder Pro. I think I need a keyboard tray to get the keyboard and mouse off the floor.|
|An overall shot of the east end of the layout. Louisa is to the right and Melton (the location of the Pyrofax gas plant) is located at the bulge on the left.|
|An overall shot of the west end of the layout. The bridge over Virginia route 15/33 is visible toward the front of the shot on the right and the staging tracks are on the left. In this view, we’re looking toward the duckunder that allows access to the layout area from the rest of the basement.|
|In this shot, we’re looking into the layout area from outside. The Westvaco siding is to the left and staging to the right.|
|I’ve installed the panel connectors for the hand-held throttles, throttle pockets (from MicroMark), and the FlexLink controls for the Blue Point switch machines.|
|I had originally ordered the throttle pockets for my old layout. As a result, I ended up short one throttle pocket. When I went to order it, I noted that they also had cup holders. What’s a layout without cup holders?|
|The next step is to rough in the scenery with foam insulation. In this shot, the first pieces of foam have been cut and placed onto the layout.|
|This is as far as I’ve gone with the foam so far.|
|The grade crossing at Doctors Road was just a short walk from my family’s property, so I often walked there to wait for trains. That made it one of my required scenes on the layout. It was the first place that I started scenery on the old layout and it seemed only fitting to start there on this layout. On my previous layout, I had included a portion of Rt. 33 and the whole S-curve from the road to the grade crossing. This time, I started by printing a Google satellite photo of the area and worked out the distances to scale. If I had built the scene to scale, I would have needed nearly 3 feet from the track centerline to Rt. 33. Since I don’t have that kind of space, I chose to model only Doctors Road and leave Rt. 33 out in the aisle. I marked the outline for the road using chart tape (most markers will bleed through paint and other scenery materials).|
|The next step was to cut some 1/2" foam in the shape of the road.|
|In this shot, I’ve begun roughing in the land forms with foam and Sculptamold. If you look closely, you can see that I marked some of the foam with a marker. Go ahead: ask me how I know that marker will bleed through.|
|The dirt around the Doctors Road grade crossing has a yellowish or orangish color that I’ve never seen elsewhere. I scooped up a bit on my last trip to visit the Piedmont (Ok, ok, I drove 3 hours to get there just to get a small container of dirt). Then I had Home Depot match the color in a cheap, flat latex paint. I put down a heavy coat of paint and then sifted dirt over the wet paint. So far, I have a nice desert.|
|I was never really happy with my representation of Doctors Road on the old layout. I had covered the road surface with a mix of sifted dirt and Woodland Scenics gray N scale ballast. It never really looked like a dirt road to me. This time, I spent a lot of time studying photos of dirt roads. This is what I came up with. I usually sift my dirt with an old kitchen strainer. This time, I took that sifted dirt and sifted it again through a cheap pair of pantyhose (only .69 at the local drugstore). I covered the road surface with that fine powder. Then I used what was left in the container (what had gone through the sifter, but not the pantyhose) to edge the travel lanes.|
|Beginning to get rid of the desert look.|
|I still need more vegetation, but it’s beginning to look like the real place.|
|In this shot I’ve added more trees and grass, along with electric utility poles and some yellow flowers (it is spring, after all). There’s still more to add, but the scene is looking fairly complete.|
|I always intended to add the lineside telegraph poles on my old layout, but never got around to it. This time I have and it really makes a difference.|
|Here’s an overall view of the Doctors Road grade crossing scene.|
|This view is from just west of the crossing.|
|Here’s an overall view of the beginning of work in Melton. I’ve roughed in landforms with foam and laid down a first coat of dirt from the actual location. Along the front edge you can see the .060 styrene I’m using for Route 33.|
|One issue that I had to solve was how to deal with the scenery on the far side of the tracks. On the prototype, there’s a relatively flat space, then an embankment. One the other side of the embankment the land drops down and the telegraph line poles go down into that depression. Then the land comes back up and there’s a line of trees (or there were in 1970). I didn’t have room for all of that. My answer was a photo backdrop of trees. In this shot, I’ve blended on end of the backdrop into a stand of 3D trees.|
|This is just a test shot to see how the photo backdrop looks behind the gas plant office.|
|Here’s west end of the Louisa passing siding. It does bother me a little that this scene is visible from the Doctors Road grade crossing, but there’s only so much space in the basement...|
|I was looking for a way to transition from the Doctors Road scene to Louisa. My normal answer is to use a thick stand of trees. The problem in this case was that I need access to the tracks to couple and uncouple cars when switching Louisa. What I settled on was a corn field.|
|The remains of a wooden ramp still stand along the tracks in Louisa, but they’re in rough shape. That makes it hard to tell what the ramp really looked like. I decided that a Blair Line ramp would be a good stand in. To bring it up to the right height, I added a base of ⅛" Masonite.|
|Documents described the feed service building as a metal shed, bit it was fairly large for a shed. I opted to use a Rix building. I had to scratchbuild a base to match the height of the wooden ramp.|
You are visitor number
to this site since the new counter was inaugurated on June 28, 2004.
This site was originally established in 1997.
|Mail comments to:||Larry Z. Daily|
Please note that, due to a huge volume of spam coming in on my email account, I’ve had to change my email address. The new address is firstname.lastname@example.org (but remove the nospam and the dot before piedmontsub.com).
Copyright © 1997-2017 Larry Z. Daily. All rights reserved.
All materials on this Web site are protected by United States copyright law. This includes, but is not limited to, articles and graphics. Unless otherwise indicated, these materials are the property of Larry Z. Daily and may not be used without prior written permission of Larry Z. Daily
|My Guestbook||The author strongly supports||Site edited with||Photos edited with||Maps created with||Tooltips created with BoxOver||The site counter is a product of|